Creating a list of the 15 best whiskies for Old Fashioned cocktails involves selecting whiskies that can stand up to the other flavors in the drink while still providing a satisfying drinking experience. Here’s a curated list, including flavor profile, alcohol content, available volumes, average price, and famous reasons for each:
Buffalo Trace Bourbon
Caramel, vanilla, and spice. Alcohol content: around 45%. Available volumes: 750 ml. Average price: $25–$35. Famous for its versatility in cocktails due to its balanced flavor profile and affordability.
Eagle Rare Bourbon
Honey, oak, and cinnamon. Alcohol content: around 45%. Available volumes: 750 ml. Average price: $30–$40. Famous for its smoothness and complexity, it adds depth to old-fashioned cocktails.
Woodford Reserve Bourbon
Flavor profile: toasted oak, vanilla, and caramel. Alcohol content: around 45.2%. Available volumes: 750 ml. Average price: $30–$40. Famous for its rich and well-balanced flavor, it enhances the depth of Old Fashioned cocktails.
Bulleit Bourbon
Flavor profile: bold spice, maple, and dried fruit. Alcohol content: around 45%. Available volumes: 750 ml. Average price: $25–$35. Famous for its high rye content, it adds complexity and character to Old Fashioned cocktails.
Four Roses Single Barrel Bourbon
Flavor profile: floral, fruity, and spicy. Alcohol content: around 50%. Available volumes: 750 ml. Average price: $40–$50. Famous for its single-barrel expression, it provides a robust and flavorful base for Old Fashioned cocktails.
Maker’s Mark Bourbon
Flavor profile: caramel, vanilla, and baking spices. Alcohol content: around 45%. Available volumes: 750 ml. Average price: $25–$35. Famous for its smooth and approachable taste, it is a popular choice for classic cocktails like the Old Fashioned.
Old Forester 1920 Prohibition Style Bourbon
Flavor profile: rich oak, caramel, and dark fruit. Alcohol content: around 57.5%. Available volumes: 750 ml. Average price: $50–$60. Famous for its bold flavor profile, it adds depth and complexity to Old Fashioned cocktails.
Knob Creek Bourbon
Flavor profile: rich oak, vanilla, and caramel. Alcohol content: around 50%. Available volumes: 750 ml. Average price: $30–$40. Famous for its full-bodied flavor and high proof, it stands out in old-fashioned cocktails.
Wild Turkey 101 Bourbon
Flavor profile: bold spice, caramel, and vanilla. Alcohol content: 50.5%. Available volumes: 750 ml. Average price: $20–$30. Famous for its high proof and robust flavor, it is a favorite for adding depth to old-fashioned cocktails.
Russell’s Reserve 10-Year-Old Bourbon
Flavor profile: caramel, oak, and baking spices. Alcohol content: around 45%. Available volumes: 750 ml. Average price: $40–$50. Famous for its well-aged expression, it provides richness and complexity to Old Fashioned cocktails.
Basil Hayden’s Bourbon
Flavor profile: light spice, honey, and citrus. Alcohol content: around 40%. Available volumes: 750 ml. Average price: $40–$50. Famous for its smooth and mellow taste, it complements the flavors of Old Fashioned cocktails.
Blanton’s Original Single Barrel Bourbon
Flavor profile: caramel, citrus, and baking spices. Alcohol content: around 46.5%. Available volumes: 750 ml. Average price: $60–$70. Famous for its collectible bottle design and exceptional quality, it elevates the experience of old-fashioned cocktails.
Angel’s Envy Bourbon
Flavor profile: port wine finish, caramel, and dried fruit. Alcohol content: around 43.3%. Available volumes: 750 ml. Average price: $50–$60. Famous for its unique finishing process in port wine barrels, it adds complexity and depth to Old Fashioned cocktails.
High West Double Rye!
Flavor profile: spicy, herbal, and caramel. Alcohol content: around 46%. Available volumes: 750 ml. Average price: $35–$45. Famous for its blend of straight rye whiskies, it provides a bold and flavorful base for Old Fashioned cocktails.
Colonel E.H. Taylor Small Batch Bourbon
Flavor profile: caramel, vanilla, and baking spices. Alcohol content: around 50%. Available volumes: 750 ml. Average price: $40–$50. Famous for its historical significance and high quality, it is a standout choice for old-fashioned cocktails.
These whiskies are renowned for their quality, flavor profiles, and ability to elevate classic cocktails like the Old Fashioned, ensuring a delightful drinking experience.
